bekah301's Red wedding

I really want to use a common patten through out the wedding. I want to use it on the invites for the side pockets (3rd pic). For the ceremony I want to line the aisle with pedestals like in the fourth pic but make them black with a thin piece of fabric draped over (table runner style) with the pattern. Then I want to use it on the table runners, the card box, and for the favor boxes, in the bathrooms and anywhere else I can think of.

So here's the issue:
Is the fabric in the 1st pic close enough to the paper in the 2nd pic to use them both together?
Or maybe I could use the paper I used originally on the invites with the fabric? (it fuzzy paper though, I'm not sure about it, it feels kind of cheap/tacky to me)
The paper would be on the invites, the favors and water bottles. Maybe the card box.
The fabric would be on the table runers, the pedestals in the ceremony, in the bathroom and maybe on the card box.

Do ya'll think this would look ok since nothing wold be right next to each other or do I need a new fabric or a new paper? Anyone know where I can find a replacement (trust me I've been looking everywhere!) I like using gift wrap because it is cost effective.