I've had this vision in my head for quite a while now and I'm happy to say that I finally did the project last week!
I used Microsoft Word to design the menu text. Then, I downloaded many fonts from searchfreefonts.com. I kept changing fonts until I narrowed it down to ones I liked.
I bought the cool natural paper at a craft store months ago. I think it was called eucalyptis paper or something like that. Finally, I bought dark brown textured cardstock from the scrapbooking section of a craft store and moss green grosgrain ribbon.
Took forever to cut all the paper just right on a paper cutter and to punch holes on the top and thread the ribbon through. I think all the time spent was worth it though! I'm very happy with how they turned out. I think they look pretty damn good if I do say so myself :)